The HBO show girl exploded onto the scene in its first season and has since won many awards. Like all good shows, it has also generated much polarizing opinions and arose controversy. I am a bit late to jump on the bandwagon but I must say that I am sure glad that I did. There's something so real about these girls that invokes both distain for their spoiled and entitled ways and yet as someone in their age bracket, I find that I really do connect to these characters in a much deeper way.
The show revolves around 4 girls in their early twenties who are living in New York City. They are newly independent and are basically trying to find their footing. The show is often tooted for its unconventional realism.
Much of the criticism of the show has stemmed from the fact that these girls do not actually represent the modern young 20 somethings. Some have said that the show is too white. The girls are annoyingly spoiled but still act like they are poor and can't afford to eat. It is unrealistic in that they pretend to live the life of pauper trying to make it in the big city but do not be fooled. Each one of these girls have a safety net of wealth to fall back on. Even though Lena Dunham's character was cut off from her parents in the pilot episode, her parents would inevitably come to her aid should she be in any real crisis. It has even been compared to Gossip Girl in that these are shallow, self-involved characters caught in a drama of their own making.
That's according to many critics of the show. And I agree.
Sorta. After watching the first two seasons of the show on DVD, I have come to the conclusion that these characters are self-absorbed and annoying and entitled. But I also find that incredibly relatable. As a young 20 something myself, I would definitely describe myself and most of my peers as selfish and self absorbed. We are probably annoying and spoiled as well, but honestly, if there ever is a time to be self-absorbed, it would be your twenties. I think that maybe your teenage years are when you are beginning to learn about the world and the rebellious teen is just someone trying to explore that world. But in your twenties, you kinda already have an idea of what's out there, but now you have a college degree and is mostly trying to figure how to fit into the world. People always say that your teenage years are very formative but I really think that much more so then that, your twenties are the most formative and it is probably the period of greatest self discovery.
And I think that the show Girls does a fabulous job of depicting that time of our lives. As for the spoiled and shallowness, I definitely would not say that Hannah and Marnia come form the same crop as Blair and Serena of Gossip Girls. They certainly do not enjoy that same previleges as the characters of Gossip Girl and they seem, to me, very standard products of the modern day middle class family.
What makes this show very realistic and relatable is its ability to depict our modern, self-aware but insecure girl that is desperately trying to find her life in the big city. I can honestly say that some of the situations and story lines for these characters are so realistic and hits so close to home that I can't help but cringe when watching it.
Another thing that is pointed out again and again, is really how bleak these characters lives are. Its almost depressing to watch. It refreshing departure from the glamourous lives of the Carrie and Samantha of Sex and the City or that of Serena and Blair. Here, in the Girl's version of New York, there are no glamourous galas and prestigious nightclubs and exclusive restaurants. But watching this show and observing their lives really can be quite depressing. I guess maybe the overall message to take away from Girls is that reality sucks. Face it?! I think that Hannah herself on the show said it best, she is just a voice of a generation. One show can't possibly represent all the different perspectives of our generation.
The optimist in me is rooting for these characters. I believe that they will succeed and land on their feet. Regardless, Girls is the first show in a long time that has provoked this much thought in me. And for that, whether you agree with its depiction of our generation or not, it deserves an A+